Crispy Potato Roast Recipe

November 27, 2009

in Foodie

I’ve had several of you ask about the Crispy Potato Roast recipe I made on Thanksgiving. It was from Everyday Food Magazine – the most recent edition – in the Holiday Dinner section. I can’t find the recipe on the Martha Stewart website yet, so here is a quick recap of it for you.


Preheat oven to 375° F. Mix 3 tbsp melted butter with 3 tbsp olive oil. Brush some of that mixture in the bottom of a round baking dish, about 9″ or so. Thinly slice 4lbs (it was 6 potatoes for me) of russet potatoes. You could use a knife, but really a slicer or mandolin works so much quicker (this is the OXO slicer I use that is very inexpensive). After you slice each potato keep it stacked together, as best you can, and stand it upright in the dish. Do this with all the potatoes – they should be fairly snug when you are done. Slice 3 or 4 shallots thickly and wedge in between the slices here and there. Sprinkle all with coarse salt and I also used some freshly cracked black pepper. Also sprinkle (recipe says option but I used it) 1/2 to 1 tsp of red-pepper flakes. Then brush the rest of the butter/oil mixture over the top of the potatoes. Bake for about 1 hour and 45 minutes. Now in the original recipe it says bake 1 hour 15 minutes and then add 8 sprigs of thyme and finish baking the rest of the time. I didn’t have any sprigs of thyme on hand and I knew Taylor wouldn’t not like just sprinkling on dried thyme – so I just left that out. Everyone loved the potatoes!

  • Sara A Broers

    This recipe rocks!!!!! Can't wait to try this.

  • jamaise

    Sounds yummy and looks very pretty :)

  • karenmed409

    Thanks for sharing.!!!

  • HODGEPODGESPV

    slurp!

  • Kelly

    I was actually planning on making this for Christmas dinner. Do you think that I could cook it in a 9" glass pie plate? I don't have any other round baking dishes.

  • RobynsOnlineWorld

    Not sure how well it would work in a pie plate Kelly – you need the sides to be tall enough to hold the potatoes upright. If you have another baking dish that is taller, even if it isn't round, I would try that instead.

  • Kelly

    Thanks, Robyn. I might just switch to a square dish. I'm very literal-minded when reading recipes :)

  • Anonymous

    thank you for posting this! it's christmas day and I had planned to prepare this but accidentally threw out this EF issue. mild panic averted. cheers :)

  • RobynsOnlineWorld

    Glad to help out! So how did it turn out?

  • Marianne

    Can you please clarify the last sentences about the "time" and the "thyme"?

    It cooks for 1 and 3/4 hours and when do you add the thyme? I'm guessing for the whole roast time.

    Was I the only one this confused? ;-)

  • RobynsOnlineWorld

    Sorry about that Marianne. If you are going to add the thyme to the recipe, do it 30 minutes before it's done (at 1 hour and 15 minutes). I corrected that sentence in the post too so others wouldn't be confused.

Previous post:

Next post: