Why you should grate and shred your own cheese

by Robyn Wright on September 26, 2012

in Food

Shred your own cheese for better taste

Grabbing those bags of shredded cheese at the grocery store is very convenient. I still do buy shredded cheese sometimes, but I am trying to quit doing it and go to always shredding or grating my own cheese. Why? Taste is my biggest reason.

When you buy shredded cheese there are additives. Primarily cellulose which is a natural ingredient and it is used to prevent the shredded cheese from clumping together. Some people get upset at that cellulose is normally made from trees, but that is not what bothers me. It is the fact that it does change the texture, and taste to me, of the cheese.

If you have grated cheese yourself, especially something like cheddar, you surely noticed that the cheese was much moister than what you get in a bag. Have you taken a nibble of that freshly grated cheese? We all do it and it is easy to taste the difference. Think about when you may have gotten a salad that has grated cheese at a restaurant. Is there one place where the cheese just seems moister and better? Chances are they are grating the cheese freshly.

Another problem with buying the pre-shredded cheese is that it does not melt as easily as freshly grated cheese. I actually have found that some brands are harder to melt than others even. It is the ingredients used to keep the cheese from caking together that actually make it harder to melt. If you are not going to switch over to freshly grating your own cheese all the time, I really suggest you at least try to make the switch for any recipe that you want the cheese to melt in.

Parmesan cheese is a special case for us. I buy both wedges of Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese and I buy the Kraft Parmesan Cheese in the green can. Most of us grew up with the green can and for me, on the regular easy spaghetti dinners the green can is the flavor and texture I want. However, for most of my other recipes I opt to grate the wedge of cheese instead for a much different flavor. When I post recipes here on my blog I try to make sure to tell you if you can use the green can or need the real deal for that particular recipe. Buying a wedge of Parmigiano-Reggiano may seem expensive, but the different in taste is worth it and it lasts a very long time in your refrigerator since it is a hard cheese.

Do you buy your cheese already grated or shredded or do you do it yourself?

© 2012, Robyn Wright. All rights reserved.

  • http://www.facebook.com/jolynne.shane Jo-Lynne Shane

    I so totally agree!!! I shred all my own cheese and it tastes SO MUCH BETTER.

  • http://twitter.com/4hatsandfrugal Amiyrah Martin

    If there is a fantastic deal on the shredded, yup, I buy it. But, every once in a while they have great deals on block cheese and since the blocks are usually around 16oz, shredding those instead of buying the bags make the best all time deal. The key is to wait until the blocks go on sale, grab them up and freeze.

    • http://www.RobynsOnlineWorld.com/ Robyn’s Online World

      Do you just keep the blocks of cheese in the same wrapper you buy them in when you freeze them? Or do you have to repackage it a certain way for freezing? Do you notice a texture change after freezing?

  • Tiffany Winner

    i just started grating my own so i can buy large hunks of good quality cheese. Shredding it myself cuts down on packaging waste. thismomwins@gmail.com

    • http://www.RobynsOnlineWorld.com/ Robyn’s Online World

      That is a great point about it cutting down on packaging waste too!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002632865465 Krystel Warden

    i love grating cheese when i greafte my chese i put i in macroni pasta lasgna etc and then let it let melt
    yum

    • http://www.RobynsOnlineWorld.com/ Robyn’s Online World

      Yummy!

  • terrik

    I do both, and I need one of those grinder spin around cheese grater things like they have in restaurants. What are those called?? I’ve grated fingertips before and that’s no fun!

    I think block cheese lasts longer, tastes better and used to be cheaper. Now it seems like the prices are fairly even. Maybe it’s awful, but I’ll go with bagged cheese if I know I’m going to use it all in a day or two, esp. for lasagna, but I buy blocks of sharp cheddar, pepperjack, etc.

    • http://www.RobynsOnlineWorld.com/ Robyn’s Online World

      Those are rotary graters. I had one but it ended up breaking. I went to a small microplaner for my parmesan cheese wedge at the table instead.

  • Ingrid

    We rarely ever buy cheese already grated. I agree that the taste is much better when you grate your own. I guess I’m just an old fashion cook!

  • GlArthy

    haha!!
    Now this is a topic I like because I eat cheese Monday to Monday – the best dairy product ever! Since I eat it daily I go for the Mozzarella cheese; this is better at not creating cholesterol as cheddar would. Cheddar is tastier and that’s what so catching. It took me a while to develope a taste for mozzarella but since aquiring the ‘taste’ for it there’s no stopping.
    Mozzarella could be a bit tricky though to melt. Macaroni Pie is no macaroni and cheese for me, it is the real deal and, you would not believe the finish it gets; one would think one is eating a pizza ;-o)
    Yep, when you got your grandmother’s recipe ‘down-pat’ that is no sharing because you want to keep the secret – something like the Kernel lol. Without cheese (and a little something else), this would not be possible.
    Oh, I got side-tracked here, can you tell? Topic: I don’t do the shredding thing, I agree with all who says it does not taste the same.
    Cheese (Mozzarella), take a bow – I love you too much. There is just no substitute! :o)

    • http://www.RobynsOnlineWorld.com/ Robyn’s Online World

      I’ve not heard of macaroni pie

  • http://rhymeschemesanddaydreams.wordpress.com Auriette

    We take the easy way out on some cheeses, but for the you-can-only-get-it-in-St.-Louis Provel cheese, we order 5-pound blocks and shred or slice ourselves as needed. Hubby can’t live without it.

  • AngelaLilly

    I could not agree more! Add organic to the mix and its even more noticeable! (i.e. conventional shredded cheese flavor vs organic you shred it flavor). I will use shredded cheese as a topping like on tacos…but if I need it for a recipe or in something where it melts, I buy the chunks.

  • Shannon Whitfield

    We do both, cheese is expensive and it depends how tight we are that month. Sometimes we buy shredded if it’s going on top of a quick pasta bake or something.. but living near Amish country here we like to splurge once in a while and buy some locally made cheeses..there’s nothing in the world like an Amish Big Eye Swiss or Pepperjack. So delicious!

    • http://www.RobynsOnlineWorld.com/ Robyn’s Online World

      Ohhh I bet that Amish cheese is good!

  • http://twitter.com/rkosully Robin

    You are such a good foodie. I agree that grated cheese never tastes as good. We actually don’t eat that much cheese but I do try to buy the bigger blocks.

  • http://www.facebook.com/nancy.lara.712 Nancy Lara

    i do buy the green can for parmesian, but for cheddar or mozzarella for recipes i grate my own, definately tastes fresh and soft compared to preshredded

  • http://welcome2mydailylife.blogspot.com/ Linda M. Ramos

    We have been learning so much about additives in our home. If I could eat cheese, I would definitely be shredding it. I am no longer buying shredded cheese for my daughter either.

  • Ravzie

    If I were to grate my own, my meals would include little bits of my fingertips…
    I do like fresh grated better also. I use the green can Parm for cooking only, not topping meals.

    • http://www.RobynsOnlineWorld.com/ Robyn’s Online World

      Use a guard with the cheese when you grate it to avoid scraping your knuckles and fingertips :)

  • http://www.redneckrosie.com/ Rose

    We do a lot of our grating here at home, even potatoes. However, I have yet to grate Parmesan cheese here at home. I’m a multi-tasker today, so I have my grocery list beside me. I have to do that in the next couple of weeks. I think it’d go great with the tortellini I’m planning on making.

  • Stephanie Olmsted

    I actually buy shredded cheese in a bag but I buy parmesan in the wedge only. We have tried to do the shred it yourself but with two kids and rushing for dinner it seems to take forever to get dinner done. I do like the way it taste better when it is grated fresh. I just got buy one get one free on chunk cheese at my grocery store this morning. I think I will got get one more later. Limit two free.

  • Diana Hayes

    Robyn, I always grate my own cheese. The best grater for Parmesan is a microplane. We grate right over our plates now.

    Try the Food saver system for grated cheese. You can reseal the bags and suck out the air to help the cheese last longer.

    • http://www.RobynsOnlineWorld.com/ Robyn’s Online World

      Agree on the microplane!

      I will have to get a Food Saver I guess. I had a different brand one that they sold a gagillion of on QVC about 20 years ago, but I know they have improved quite a bit since then.

  • http://www.theconfidentmom.com theconfidentmom

    I mix it up – I buy grated Cheddar at Costco, only because I can get it fairly inexpensive and it saves me time. I buy bulk Parmesan.

  • Gianna

    We buy the big 5 lb blocks of cheese and shred them ourselves. Whole milk if possible because the taste, texture and melt of the cheese is so much better.
    Also, there is nothing like a big wheel of parmesan cheese. We didn’t grow up on the green can.. just the stuff straight from Italy!

  • mefink

    I buy the bags already shredded. My hubby eats cheese so fast that it seems to time consuming to be gone so quick.

  • Cheryl Wilson

    I agree! I do use pre-shredded when time is crunched, but 9 times out of 10 I will take the time to grate my own. It melts better, the texture is better and it is a whole lot cheaper.

  • Jennifer Peaslee

    I usually buy my cheese already shredded, but on occasion we shred our own. You’re right about the taste! Maybe its the taste plus the mental satisfaction that you did it yourself and you know it’s as fresh as can be? Yum….drooling on the keyboard now…I’m a big cheese fan :) jenniferpeaslee at gmail dot com

  • mongupp

    I like fresh grated cheeses but the preshredded cheese is easy to use in a pinch!

  • Jimmy

    I usually buy shredded cheese. I’ve never really noticed a different taste. Now that you mention it, however, I do noticed the shredded in less moist.

  • MichelleS

    I never thought about that, but I would think that it would be cheaper to buy cheese in bulk, store, and then shred instead of buying expensive bags of cheese. I think it would have to with freshly grated cheese.

  • http://twitter.com/St4ceyNicole Stacey Nicole

    I have never grated cheese before but now I really really want to. We go through probably 3 bags of shredded cheese a week haha. We love our cheese. I hate additives and other ingredients that don’t need to be in cheese so I will def. be trying this out.
    Email – Stacey.brickner6@gmail.com

  • terry petero

    I also prefer shredded cheese for the taste and especially for parmigiano- reggiano and also parmesan cheese and the kids love to eat the cheese as i shred it.

Previous post:

Next post: